Legal position reviewed as at 2 November 2026
Can an employer terminate an employee simply by giving contractual notice or paying salary in lieu? Those steps may satisfy the notice obligation, but they do not conclusively resolve a statutory wrongful dismissal claim under Singapore’s Employment Act. Recent Employment Claims Tribunals (ECT) decisions have brought that distinction into sharper focus.
For employers, the practical message is straightforward: notice pay is not a complete answer. Before issuing a termination letter, assess the reason for dismissal, the supporting evidence, the required process and the employee’s entitlements.
This Q&A distinguishes contractual termination rights, official guidance and recent tribunal interpretations. It also explains why the appeal position matters.
1. Can an employer terminate employment by giving notice or paying salary in lieu?
Generally, an employer may exercise a contractual right to terminate employment by giving the required notice or paying salary in lieu. Notice of termination must be in writing.
However, two separate questions arise:
| Question | What it concerns |
|---|---|
| Has the employer complied with the contract? | Notice, payment obligations and any applicable contractual procedures. |
| Can the employee establish a statutory wrongful dismissal claim? | Whether the dismissal was “without just cause or excuse” under section 14(2) of the Employment Act. |
Compliance with a termination clause does not, by itself, determine the second question. That distinction is central to the reasoning in JGP v JGQ 2026 SGECT 1 and JJF v JJG 2026 SGECT 9.
2. What have recent Singapore employment tribunal decisions said?
Two decisions by Tribunal Magistrate Jared Kang Chern Wey are particularly relevant.
JGP v JGQ 2026 SGECT 1
The case arose from an employer’s investigation into medical-benefit claims. The employees concerned were dismissed with contractual notice, with some notice periods later commuted to salary in lieu. The Tribunal nevertheless found in favour of the six employees whose related claims it heard.
The decision distinguishes common-law wrongful dismissal, which concerns breach of the employment contract, from a statutory claim under section 14(2). It also examines the employer’s stated misconduct grounds, the disciplinary process and whether dismissal was justified.
JJF v JJG 2026 SGECT 9
The employer terminated a senior construction manager under an express contractual clause, paid salary in lieu and gave no reason at the termination meeting or in the letter. The Tribunal nevertheless found that the employee had been dismissed without just cause or excuse and awarded compensation.
The decision rejects the proposition that failure to establish discrimination necessarily means the dismissal was justified. The Tribunal treated the statutory question as distinct from both contractual compliance and proof of a prohibited motive.
These decisions should not be reduced to a blanket statement that every termination without a stated reason is wrongful. They do, however, demonstrate why employers should not assume that contractual notice and silence about the reason eliminate statutory risk.
3. Are these decisions final, or are appeals involved?
The procedural position must be described carefully.
In JGP, the published judgment records that the employer had filed applications seeking permission to appeal in all six related cases.
In JJF, the published judgment records that the employer obtained permission to appeal in May 2026 on a question of law.
Those statements establish the procedural position recorded in the judgments. They do not, by themselves, establish the subsequent outcome of the applications or appeal.
These are first-instance tribunal decisions, not appellate judgments settling every issue they discuss. Their reasoning should be distinguished from established contractual principles and the wording of the Tripartite Guidelines. The latest appeal position should be checked before relying on them for a particular termination.
4. Must an employer state a reason for termination?
MOM’s guidance states that an employer is generally not required to give a reason for termination with notice. The Tripartite Guidelines also contemplate a dismissal with notice and no stated reason that is not wrongful.
But “not required to state a reason” should not be confused with “the underlying reason can never be examined”.
In JJF, the Tribunal examined the statutory justification for dismissal even though the employer had relied on a contractual clause and had given no reason when terminating employment.
The practical approach is to identify and document the actual basis for the decision internally, then obtain advice on whether and how it should be communicated. Do not invent a reason merely to fill a gap in a termination letter.
5. Who must prove that a dismissal was wrongful?
The answer depends on the circumstances.
Under the Tripartite Guidelines, an employee dismissed with notice and without a stated reason must substantiate a wrongful reason. Where the employer cites misconduct or poor performance, the employer must prove that ground. The Guidelines also state that a dismissal is wrongful where the employer gives a reason that is proven false.
Section 27(2) of the Employment Claims Act provides specific burden-of-proof rules, including for summary dismissal under section 14(1) of the Employment Act and dismissal with notice on grounds of poor performance or misconduct. JJF examines how those rules interact with the statutory inquiry into just cause or excuse.
It would therefore be too broad to say either that “the employer always has to prove a valid reason” or that “the employee always has to prove discrimination”.
6. Is paying salary in lieu enough to avoid further compensation?
Not necessarily.
Payment in lieu addresses the notice obligation. In JJF, the employer argued that the employee had received more than his contractual entitlement and therefore had no further recoverable loss. The Tribunal distinguished that contractual position from the statutory claim and awarded compensation.
MOM’s guidance states that, where the ECT finds a dismissal wrongful, it may order reinstatement with payment for lost income or monetary compensation.
Employers should therefore avoid treating the notice payment as an automatic cap on all potential exposure.
7. Can an employer dismiss an employee for poor performance?
Poor performance can be a legitimate reason for dismissal. If the employer relies on it, however, the performance ground must be substantiated.
Before proceeding, review:
- The employee’s role and expected standards.
- Specific shortcomings and their impact.
- Performance reviews and contemporaneous feedback.
- Relevant warnings or improvement measures.
- Any procedure required by the contract or applicable policies.
- Whether the records support the explanation being given.
Recent bonuses, pay increases or confirmation after probation do not necessarily prevent a later performance dismissal. They should nevertheless be considered alongside the employer’s performance narrative. In JJF, the employee’s confirmation, bonus and salary increase formed part of the factual dispute over the employer’s alleged concerns.
Do not retrospectively construct a performance history to justify a decision already made.
8. Does poor performance justify dismissal without notice or notice pay?
Poor performance should not automatically be treated as misconduct.
The Tripartite Guidelines distinguish dismissal for poor performance, which requires notice, from dismissal without notice for established misconduct.
An employee who struggles to meet targets presents a different issue from an employee accused of dishonesty or deliberate disobedience. The correct classification affects the evidence, process and payment obligations.
Employers should not use the label “misconduct” simply to avoid paying notice.
9. When is an inquiry required before dismissal?
Section 14(1) of the Employment Act expressly addresses dismissal without notice for misconduct after due inquiry. MOM states that employers must conduct a formal inquiry before taking disciplinary action for misconduct.
MOM identifies important safeguards:
- Inform the employee of the alleged misconduct.
- Give the employee an opportunity to present their case.
- Ensure the person hearing the inquiry is not in a position suggesting bias.
A more contested issue concerns the treatment of misconduct-based dismissals where notice is given. JGP involved dismissals with notice and examined due inquiry and the employer’s disciplinary procedures in that setting. Its treatment should be distinguished from section 14(1)’s express reference to dismissal “without notice”.
The practical response is neither to assume that every ordinary termination requires a disciplinary hearing nor to assume that paying notice removes all process concerns. Where misconduct is the real basis, review the proposed inquiry and applicable procedures before acting.
10. Can an employee be suspended while misconduct is investigated?
MOM’s guidance states that suspension during a misconduct inquiry must not exceed one week without the Commissioner for Labour’s approval. The employee must receive at least half their salary during that period. If no misconduct is found, the withheld salary must be restored.
An employer seeking an extension must apply at least three working days before the initial one-week suspension ends.
Plan the investigation timetable before imposing suspension, particularly where interviews, forensic work or substantial document review may be needed.
11. What reasons for dismissal are clearly high risk?
MOM identifies wrongful dismissals as including:
- Dismissal on discriminatory grounds.
- Dismissal intended to deprive an employee of benefits or entitlements.
- Dismissal intended to punish an employee for exercising an employment right.
Examples include dismissing an employee to avoid maternity benefits or in retaliation for submitting a salary-related mediation request to TADM.
However, the recent tribunal reasoning means the analysis should not stop at asking whether one of these familiar categories has been proved. In JJF, the Tribunal expressly distinguished failure to establish discrimination from a finding that just cause or excuse existed.
12. How should redundancy be handled?
Redundancy should be assessed separately from performance or misconduct.
MOM recognises redundancy as a potentially valid reason for dismissal and directs retrenching employers to the Tripartite Advisory on Managing Excess Manpower and Responsible Retrenchment.
Before proceeding, establish the genuine business rationale, identify how roles are affected and separately check applicable retrenchment obligations.
Do not describe a position as redundant merely because that seems an easier explanation. Under the Tripartite Guidelines, a stated reason that is proven false can make the dismissal wrongful.
13. What should an employer check before issuing the termination letter?
This is a practical review tool. It does not replace an assessment of the particular employee, contract and circumstances.
| Check | Questions to resolve |
|---|---|
| Contract | What notice period, payment obligations and procedures apply? |
| Actual reason | Is the decision based on performance, misconduct, redundancy or another reason? |
| Evidence | Do contemporaneous records support the position? |
| Process | Is an inquiry or contractual procedure required? |
| Statutory risk | Are there discrimination, maternity, retaliation or other protection concerns? |
| Recent decisions | Do the ECT rulings raise issues relevant to this dismissal, and has the appeal position changed? |
| Communications | Are the letter, meeting script and internal records accurate and consistent? |
| Payments | Have salary, notice pay, leave and other entitlements been assessed? |
| Practical exit | How will handover, access, company property and confidential information be managed? |
14. When must final salary be paid?
Where an employer terminates employment, MOM states that final salary must be paid on the last day of employment. If that is not possible, it must be paid within three working days from the termination date.
Prepare an itemised calculation before communicating the decision. Depending on the circumstances, it may need to address salary, notice pay, unused leave, expenses, commission, bonus and other contractual entitlements.
Separately check whether any applicable tax-clearance or other legal requirements affect the handling of payments.
15. How quickly can an employee bring a wrongful dismissal claim?
MOM states that a wrongful dismissal claim should be filed at TADM within one month after the employee’s last day of employment. Unresolved claims may be referred to the ECT.
For managers and executives dismissed with notice or salary in lieu, MOM states that at least six months’ service is required to bring the claim through this route. Eligibility requirements should not be confused with permission to dismiss for an otherwise unlawful reason.
Employers should preserve relevant documents when a dispute is anticipated, including the contract, performance records, inquiry materials, decision-making communications, termination letter and payment calculations.
Planning to terminate an employee? Speak to Foxwood before issuing the letter.
Do not assume that a contractual termination clause or notice payment resolves every issue. The reason, evidence and process should be assessed before the decision is communicated.
Foxwood can assist employers with reviewing proposed terminations, assessing the implications of recent tribunal decisions, advising on performance and misconduct processes, and preparing termination or negotiated exit documents.
Contact Foxwood before issuing the termination letter—while there is still time to address the risks and choose the appropriate approach.
This article provides general information based on sources reviewed on 2 November 2026 and does not constitute legal advice. The tribunal judgments discussed record appeal-related steps, but those records do not establish the subsequent appellate position. Applicable law, guidance and appeal developments should be checked again before publication and before acting on a particular termination.